This page compares 3Commas and Coinrule on security, API permissions, features, and known risk incidents. It does not constitute a recommendation to use either platform. ScammerWatch does not provide financial advice. No automated trading platform guarantees profit.
Comparison of crypto trading bots
3Commas
Security 50%
Ease of use 90%
Trade automation scope 100%
Demo account 80%
Pricing and free trial 80%
Backtesting 0%
Customer support and tutorials 70%
Profitability 80%
Overall rating 78%
Coinrule
Security 100%
Ease of use 70%
Trade automation scope 100%
Demo account 80%
Pricing and free trial 90%
Backtesting 90%
Customer support and tutorials 90%
Profitability 90%
Overall rating 88%
3commas
Coinrule
Min.deposit
From 1 USD
any
Supported exchanges
Binance,Bitfinex, Bitstamp, Bybit, Kucoin, Bitmex and over 20 more
Starter 29$,Advanced 49$, Pro 99$, with discounts if for annual payment
Starter – Free
1. API Security a>1. API Security and Known Incidents
ting any third-party trading bot to your exchange account via API, configure the key with trade permissions only. Never enable withdrawal permissions. The following security incidents and disclosures are relevant to both platforms.
3Commas 50%
Coinrule 100%
3Commas security<>3Commas security
wp-block-paragraph">First and foremost, you need to make sure your trading bots are secure. 3Commas uses an encrypted API to connect to exchanges. This means that the 3Commas system communicates with exchanges back and forth during trades, but it never has real access to your funds because the system never knows your actual login data. There is no cache and everything stays within the encrypted API keys. Furthermore, the developers say it has solid Cloudflare protection tools such as DDOS protection, firewall and SSL encryption.
However, there is an ongoing situation with 3Commas in which more and more users are reporting that they lost their funds because of an API key breach. There are unauthorized trades on peoples’ accounts and lots of money was reported leaking. 3Commas responded to this recently, first attributing the problem to phishing and saying that API is safe. Still, they confirmed the problem afterward and said they were looking into it. We cannot give a definitive security grade because the final outcome of this is still unknown. Here is a confirmation of API unauthorized trades from Binance support:
Coinrule security>Coinrule security
wp-block-paragraph">Coinrule has no known security issues so far and their reputation is pretty much intact. They have a community on various social media mostly reporting being satisfied with security. Coinrule works with private keys that are kept with the users and saved on some detached data storage with AES-256 encryption.
Coinrule has fewer exchanges (12) supported, but they are mostly top-tier, like with 3Commas. It also listens to the community requests for adding new exchanges, and is doing so at a good rate.
3Commas is an automated trading platform offering a variety of trading bots, such as DCA short bots, DCA long bots, or grid bots. The platform and the bots are easy to use and are built smart, but in order to maximize the potential of each setup, the interface needs to be understood thoroughly and there is a rather big learning curve when using 3Commas.
Coinrule offers fully automated trading bots that use technical and fundamental analysis to understand trading charts. They have a variety of built-in bots in their platform, but you can also create your own bots of different types. They are really easy to understand and you don’t need to know how to code to use them.
They are both automated, but Coinrule gets the win for its automated trading being easier.
Both bots offer the option of using a demo account for paper trading.
3Commas paper trading works on Binance spot markets and offers a maximum amount of 100 orders. The simulated fees are 0.1%. At the moment, this feature is only reserved for the paid programs of 3Commas. Be careful that it also matches the level of the active subscription, so, for example, a Starter plan means unlimited trades but only one Grid or Dollar cost averaging bot.
Coinrule offers a virtual account with paper trading on Binance, and they say it mirrors actual trades properly. You get 10 BTC, 10000 USDT and real market conditions to trade in. Both limit orders and market orders are available on the demo exchange, and the simulated exchange fee is 0.1% to make it as realistic as possible.
The big advantage of Coinrule here is paper trading on a free account. Both bots offer similar benefits in relation to paper trading quality and possibilities, so Coinrule takes a slight edge.
3Commas has the option of a free trial that lasts three days and opens all the features for you. After the trial ends, you will be redirected to the free subscription plan. Here you can see the differences between account levels:
Coinrule has a great free account option that lasts indefinitely instead of a free trial that will end. Here is what you get from trading tools from free, hobbyist, trader, and pro plans respectively:
3Commas does not offer backtesting because they believe the results may be misleading. On the other hand, Coinrule has a full-fledged backtesting option in its trading terminal. You will use an encrypted template which guarantees its security, and the interface with trading signals is very user-friendly. We will not include this grade in the final score because 3Commas does not have it as an option.
7. Customer suppo>7. Customer support and Tutorials
3Commas has a learning hub blog for various tutorials, and lots of useful information about strategies, testing and tutorials can be found online since it is a well-known bot with a large base of followers. They have a live chat for customer support whose typical response time is under five minutes. Still, we also have to include the response to the current API leak affair into the whole picture, and this is yet to be seen. So far, they have been satisfactory.
Coinrule has a live chat function on the platform and email or social media to turn to for help. Its advantage is that the support helps not only with technical issues, but also with trading strategies. Coinrule is very active on Twitter and lots of useful information and updates can be found there.
What to Check Bef>What to Check Before Using Either Platform
wp-block-paragraph">Before connecting 3Commas, Coinrule, or any third-party bot to your exchange account, verify the following: API keys are configured with trade permissions only and withdrawal is disabled. IP whitelisting is enabled on your exchange. You have reviewed the platform’s terms of service for liability clauses. You understand that a security incident on the bot platform’s side — regardless of fault — can result in unauthorized trades on your connected exchange account. ScammerWatch does not recommend either platform. If you have experienced unauthorized trades or fund loss connected to either service, submit a report at scammerwatch.com/report-a-scam.
FAQ
FAQhema-faq wp-block-yoast-faq-block">
Are 3Commas and Coinrule legit?
Both of them are listed as verified cryptocurrency trading bot companies on Truspilot.com, with 3Commas leading with a higher grade – 4.4/5 to 4/5. Officially, they are both legit as crypto trading bot platforms and their crypto trading bots are not a scam. Just make sure to follow the current 3Commas API keys situation and see how it resolves, because the API leak is not a minor issue.
Are these two crypto bots risky?
They are not inherently risky, in the sense that any real and legit crypto trading bot is as risky as their users’ decisions and trading strategies. What they have going for them is that they are easy to use and beginner friendly, and they have a decent-sized online community that you can follow and learn from it to further reduce risk.
Which crypto bot is the best: 3Commas or Coinrule?
Objectively, they both have advantages, and they support traders with many helpful tools to enhance trading, whether in speed, ease of use, or potential profit.
ScammerWatch prepares structured fraud reports with URLs, screenshots, timestamps, reporter statements, and technical metadata. Provider teams can request a sample report format before enabling direct intake
I'm a full-time blockchain developer and digital marketer with a degree in computer science from the University of Washington. Currently a software engineer at Nash.io, responsible for developing and maintaining the software that powers the Nash platform.
